Cancel your plans, this budget is a biggie

Michael Bennet
09:45pm May 05 2021

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg says there will be no sharp pivots towards “austerity”. (Getty)

The leaks are flowing, the political jostling intensifying and the anticipation rising. 

Yes, it’s federal budget time again, complete with the usual talk of “winners” and “losers”. 

As always, some have already been locked in after pre-announcements – families with multiple children in childcare are set to win from the government’s newly minted $1.7 billion plan, along with the elderly from the $2.5bn allotted to aged care. 

Westpac chief economist Bill Evans says women and industries still impacted by COVID-19 restrictions, such as tourism and education, are also set to benefit when Treasurer Josh Frydenberg hands down the government’s most important annual economic document on Tuesday night. 

The “losers”? There’ll naturally be some.

But with the Treasurer assuring no “sharp pivots towards austerity”, perhaps fewer cohorts will feel hard done by than usual. 

And stepping back, all taxpayers are set to win from what Evans describes as the “extraordinary” improvement in deficit and debt thanks to the economy’s roaring recovery and soaring iron ore prices.
 

For 2020-21, he expects the deficit will come in at $155bn – or more than $40bn better than tipped in December’s Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook. Others, such as forecasters at UBS, think it could be even better, printing at $148bn. 

Either way, the task of repaying the billions of dollars racked up to offset the economic pain of COVID-19 will be a little easier, Westpac Economics expecting net debt to moderate to $731bn in 2021-22, some $67bn lower than in MYEFO.

It’s clearly a far happier backdrop than last year’s delayed budget seven months ago, reinforced by the Reserve Bank’s sizeable economic upgrades this week. 

But a looming federal election, vaccine rollout problems, the national border remaining closed and ongoing snap lockdowns mean this budget is no less important. 
 

Evans says it’s clear the budget strategy is to “go for growth” and generate more jobs to achieve the goal of getting the unemployment rate – which has slid to a far better than expected 5.6 per cent – down to 4.5 per cent over time.   

“The budget position and the outlook for the budget have improved markedly,” Evans says in his budget preview, acknowledging Australia’s economic and health “miracle” in the past year following massive government and RBA support. 

“Over the whole budget period out to 2024-25 we expect the underlying fiscal position will have improved from deficits totalling $511.6bn in MYEFO to $400bn, including an estimated $62bn in new policy measures.”

But despite the remarkable turnaround in budget fortunes, Evans laments that the government appears likely to squander the opportunity to accelerate tax reform by bringing forward “stage three” of their personal income tax cut plan. 

Slated for 2025, stage three removes the 32.5 per cent and 37 per cent marginal tax rates in favour of 30 per cent, flattening the tax structure between income of $45,000 and $200,000, when the top rate of 45 per cent kicks in. 

Speculation has instead centred on the Low and Middle Income Tax Offset (LMITO) being extended for another year. But Evans says this would result in another round of “double compensation”, given the policy was originally introduced to compensate taxpayers earning up to $125,000 before stage two of the tax cuts came in, but these were accelerated to 2020-21 and the LMITO extended amid the pandemic. 

He argues another extension is not tax reform and that bringing forward stage three would create a “simpler, more competitive and aspirational tax system”. It is also a “sensible and affordable strategy” to support growth and full employment, he says, putting the net cost at around $10bn if the LMITO was also not continued. 
 

Bill Evans (left) with former Treasurer Wayne Swan in May 2010 just prior to that year's budget when Australia was recovering from the GFC. (Getty)

“In extending the LMITO for a third year the government will be missing the opportunity to bring forward tax reform,” he says, noting it will result in four years of no tax reform being delivered. “The reforms to childcare that will be announced in the budget are aimed at improving participation in the labour market – lower tax rates also boost participation while increasing disposable incomes and spending power.” 

Morgan Stanley strategist Chris Nicol agrees the government is unlikely to accelerate stage three. But with a reduction in tax relief looming in 2023 as the stage one tax rebates roll off, he says the government may “address” this with some tax tweaks without touching stage three.

Indeed, Nicol believes this budget will be closely watched by consumers. 

He says the “political and economic incentives” are strong enough to see around $50bn in discretionary spending announced over the forward estimates, but warns that households shouldn’t expect the same support as in last year’s crisis-orientated budget following the strong gains across the labour market. Remarkably, total employment is above pre-COVID levels. 
 

Likewise, Nicol says the booming housing market means further “demand-boosting housing measures” like Homebuilder and First Home Buyer Deposit Scheme are unlikely. 

“Despite Australia's significant outperformance on economic and health outcomes over 2020 relative to most other countries, the federal government's polling numbers have declined over the past six months and recent polls show it trails the opposition on a two-party preferred basis – which likely further increases voter focus on what the budget means for them,” he says. 

As for Evans, he expects an even larger spending cash splash of around $62bn over coming years, or $20bn in 2021-22, a further $20bn-odd the year after and around $11bn in each of the two following years. 

And with the RBA having indicated unemployment needs to fall to 4 per cent, or even below, before igniting wages growth and inflation, the government’s spending beyond aged care, women and COVID relief are tipped to have a familiar ring to it: jobs and growth. 

“The $20bn package of spending measures in 2021-22 will likely include a range of other initiatives spanning a broad spectrum of issues – with a particular focus on jobs and more jobs,” Evans says.

“This may include: families, small business incentives, education and training, skills creation, health care, the NDIS, climate change and energy policies, defence, infrastructure, as well as addressing the issue of housing affordability through social housing and rent assistance.” 

Cancel your Tuesday night plans…. 

Full Budget coverage. 

The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the Westpac Group.

The information in this article is general information only, it does not constitute any recommendation or advice; it has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs and you should consider its appropriateness with regard to these factors before acting on it. Any taxation position described is a general statement and should only be used as a guide. It does not constitute tax advice and is based on current tax laws and our interpretation. Your individual situation may differ and you should seek independent professional tax advice. You should also consider obtaining personalised advice from a professional financial adviser before making any financial decisions in relation to the matters discussed.
 

Michael Bennet

Michael Bennet was inaugural Editor of Westpac Wire from June 2017 to December 2021. He joined Westpac after more than 12 years in journalism, most recently at The Australian as the national newspaper’s banking reporter based in Sydney. Michael has worked at various News Corp publications and other media companies covering industries including financial services, resources, industrials, markets and economics. He is originally from Perth, Western Australia, where he also wrote across magazines covering the arts with a focus on music.

Don't miss

Related articles

Spending and surprises: Federal Budget 2021 in a few minutes

By Josh Wall
Head of Video, Westpac Wire

New order: Will Biden’s big spending work?

By Michael Bennet
Former Editor, Westpac Wire

Post the polls: 3 min US economic snapshot

By Elliot Clarke
Senior Economist, Westpac

Browse topics